Robbery, Recovery and Restoration: Two Gold Boxes from the Rosalinde and Arthur Gilbert Collection Return Home



March 11, 2026

Robberies in museums are any museum curator’s nightmare. And this is unfortunately what happened on 20th November 2024 when three gold boxes from the Rosalinde and Arthur Gilbert Collection were stolen from the Musée Cognacq-Jay in Paris. A year later, thanks to an extensive police investigation led by the French Police, two of the three boxes were miraculously recovered, although damaged. The investigation is still ongoing for the third box. From robbery to recovery and restoration, in this post I will tell the incredible journey of these two boxes from the Gilbert Collection.

The three boxes, together with four others loaned from the Gilbert Collection, formed part of a marvellous exhibition entitled, Luxe de Poche: petits objets precieux au siècle des lumieres (28 March – 24 November 2024.

The exhibition focused on the consumption of small precious and sophisticated objects such as snuffboxes, cane handles, and other accessories quintessential of 18th-century Europe and explored the rituals of the refined everyday life, luxury and fashion in the 18th and early 19th centuries. The exhibition featured loans from important French and UK collections, alongside the three boxes lent by the Rosalinde and Arthur Gilbert Collection.

Encountering a tremendous success, the exhibition was extended until November and this is when the robbery occurred. The three Gilbert boxes lent to the exhibition were:  

A gold and stone snuffbox, by Johann Christian Neuber, Dresden, about 1780, set with a micromosaic of two doves by Giacomo Raffaelli, Rome, about 1780. Neuber was a renowned goldsmith whose signature style was to set wafer-thin stone panels, exclusively sourced from Saxony, into gold-mounted objects to create unique patterns. Raffaelli was an Italian mosaicist who turned micromosaics – a craft invented in the 18th century in the Vatican mosaic studio to create the most illusionistic mosaics – into the most fashionable art.

Snuffbox by Johann Christian Neuber, Dresden, and Giacomo Raffaelli, Rome, circa 1780, LOAN:GILBERT.353-2008.

A chrysoprase, gold and diamond snuffbox, Berlin, about 1760. This box formed part of the extensive collection of snuffboxes cherished, commissioned and even designed by Frederick ‘The Great’ II of Prussia. Out of the 300 boxes recorded in the king’s collection, 33 have been identified today and 17 of these are made of hardstones. Six boxes are made specifically of chrysoprase, including this one. It is a particularly remarkable example of 18th century gem setting by Berlin Jewellers.

Chrysoprase snuffbox, Berlin, circa 1760, LOAN:GILBERT.412-2008.

A gold and diamonds snuffbox, Berlin or St Petersburg, circa 1760. It was presented by Catherine II of Russia to the physician Thomas Dimsdale after his successive inoculation of smallpox to her and her son, the heir of Throne of Imperial Russia. This provenance makes the box absolutely unique in the world and I was personally the most upset about this box after the news of the robbery.

The ‘Dimsdale’ Snuffbox, Berlin or St Petersburg, circa 1760, LOAN:GILBERT.346-2008.

Happily, the ‘Chrysoprase’ and ‘Dimsdale’ boxes were recovered. Both boxes had been damaged, although not severely:

On the chrysoprase box, some of diamonds had been removed, their gold and silver settings had been creased or torn. Luckily all elements had been retained, including the foil which was set at the back of some diamonds to give them a bright pink or yellow colour. Naturally occurring pink, green and yellow diamonds were extremely rare and in the 18th century, the practice of colour-enhancing gems was widely carried out. To learn more about the history of this practice and the recipes used to make coloured tints read former V&A Conservator Johanna Whalley’s chapter, ‘Diamonds and Coloured Gems: The fate of foils’ in Masterpieces in Miniature: Treasures from the Rosalinde and Arthur Gilbert Collection (V&A Publishing, 2021), pp.105 – 109.

Damage to the underside of the box

For the other box, commonly referred to as ‘The Dimsdale box’, the thumbpiece had been pushed in, with some of the settings torn and badly damaged. However, luckily again all the elements – even the minutest diamonds – had been recovered safely.  

Damaged thumbpiece of Dimsdale box

The first decision to be made was then how, or if, the damage to the boxes should be restored. In some respects, the damage presented a wonderful opportunity to see elements of the box’s construction that cannot be seen in its intact state. With the diamonds dismantled, the artistry and illusion of 18th century gem setting is revealed, especially the technique of colouring gems with tinted foils, which is designed to be hidden. However, the risk of losing any of those minute elements, combined with their extreme fragility – especially the tinted foils which are also highly sensitive to light degradation – would have limited the possibility of putting them back on public display as those details can only be inspected close up, not behind the glass case.

The decision was therefore made to restore the boxes back to their original condition. A Parisian goldsmith’s studio was appointed, with decades of experience specializing in historic jewellery and gem settings for museums and private clients. Discussions continued throughout the restoration process to ensure that each conservation decision was made to our complete satisfaction. The restoration of the chrysoprase snuffbox was relatively straightforward. A general cleaning was completed first to remove dirt, glue residue and dust. This made the green colour of the chrysoprase more intense than ever. The metal elements needed to be reshaped and straightened before they were set back into their respective locations. And finally, the highly sensitive task of gently dry cleaning the foils to prepare them to be reset behind the diamonds had to be completed.

Reshaping the damaged metal elements of the Chrysoprase box
Resetting the elements that have been straightened and uncreased
Mapping the locations of the losses and preparing to reset the coloured foils
The completed conservation work on the underside of the box

The box has now been returned to its original state, especially thanks to our strict conservation criteria of having no new components added, so as not to change the historical accuracy of the materials. The only difference from its previous appearance is the fading of one foil at the front, which means that one of the diamonds doesn’t look pink anymore.

Before: The pink colour of the foil behind the diamond before the damage
After: detail indicating the fading of the foil and loss of pink colour to the diamond

The restoration of the Dimsdale box was somewhat more challenging, due to the damage to its thumbpiece. Part of the thumbpiece had been pushed in and some of the settings badly torn and squashed. Restoring this area would only have been possible by re-creating a portion of the, now missing, thumbpiece with the use of contemporary materials. The decision was taken by the Gilbert Trust for the Arts Board of Trustees that this action would have been too intrusive. Instead, it was agreed that elements should be straightened and diamonds refitted wherever possible, restoring the box to as much of its original state as possible.

The decision was taken not to remove the signs of the tools the robbers used to force open the box. It was decided that this was part of the box’s history, as an object that is already unique in the world for its fascinating provenance, and that it wouldn’t be appropriate to erase all traces of this shocking chapter.

Detail of damage to the thumbpiece of the Dimsdale box
Green dots indicate six missing diamonds that were able to be refitted
The marks and dents on the gold lid are the signs that remain of the robbers’ tools
The completed conservation work to the Dimsdale box

In keeping with the decisions of the Trustees and the V&A’s conservation policy, no new components have been added during the restoration of the box. However, a black silver patina has been added to harmonise the areas that were re-set with the original settings. This intervention is entirely reversible – the patina can be removed in future if it needed to be for any reason.

The boxes will be back on display when the Gilbert Galleries re-open on Saturday 14th March 2026.  They will reintegrate seamlessly into the galleries’ overall narrative. The chrysoprase will be presented amongst a fabulous array of gold boxes, focusing on their incredible materials and craftsmanship in Gallery 71; while the Dimsdale box will be associated with a portrait of Thomas Dimsdale himself, as Arthur Gilbert intended to reunite both objects with such a unique story in Gallery 70B.

The Chrysoprase box being installed in the new Gilbert Galleries, Gallery 71, by Alice Minter
The Dimsdale box being installed in the new Gilbert Galleries, Gallery 70B, by Alice Minter

1 comment so far, view or add yours

Comments

All that glitters is not gold Shakespeare very good blog well worth the read

Add a comment

Please read our privacy policy to understand what we do with your data.

MEMBERSHIP

Join today and enjoy unlimited free entry to all V&A exhibitions, Members-only previews and more

Find out more

SHOP

Explore our range of exclusive jewellery, books, gifts and more. Every purchase supports the V&A.

Find out more